Case Studies
Case Study - F Ball Limited

Energy saving mixing in a green factory

 A JR Boone Delta Blade Mixer has found favour at F Ball, a leading manufacturer of cementitious flooring.  The mixer is an integral part of a new factory development that combines high efficiency with extremely low energy usage.  Thorough mixing with a minimal mix cycle is key in a factory where six batches may be in process at any one time.

 John R Boone have supplied an energy efficient Horizontal Delta Blade mixer to cementitious product manufacturer F Ball Ltd for high speed mixing with low power consumption, achieving a high throughput with a very short mixing cycle.  The highly efficient process comprises weight hoppers that feed the JR Boone mixer, discharging via a ‘bomb’ door to an under hopper that feeds a packaging and palletisation line beneath; a process that requires good control and a short mixing cycle to achieve the total batch time of under two minutes for a 2 tonne mix.

 The history of F Ball, the UK’s leading producer of flooring adhesives, levelling products and grouts, goes back 125 years, originating as an ink manufacturer, moving from London to Staffordshire during the second world war and into a purpose built factory on an eight acre site in 1989.  It was in the early 1990’s that they installed their first mixer from John R Boone Limited and so began a relationship that has continued and developed, leading to their latest purchase of a Boone Horizontal Delta Blade Mixer for high speed production in their new powder mixing plant.

 The new plant is designed to produce up to 30 tonnes of blended material per hour.  At any time there may be as many as six batches within the process: one in each of the two weigh hoppers containing the bulk materials (sand, cement) together with additives such as flow promoters and set retarders; a further batch in the mixer, mixed material in the underhopper and two further batches within the packing and palletisation line.  With that amount of work in process, mixing speed and efficiency is paramount, thoroughly blending the additives throughout the bulk materials before the bomb door opens and the mixed material is deposited into the underhopper.

 A key objective for the plant was that it would have as small an environmental impact as possible, and a vital part of that objective was to minimise the energy used, for example by the use of gravity fed rather than mechanically conveyed processes and making every element of the process as energy efficient as it could be, including the mixer itself.  F Ball approached JR Boone for a solution, JR Boone proposing their Delta Blade technology.  The Delta Blade is a plough type mixer, with a precisely engineered blade shape that uses the principles of high agitator speeds to radially and axially accelerate the product formulation in a short criss-cross pattern within the mixer shell.  Higher levels of shear are produced with lower power consumption than more conventional mixers, meaning that batches are mixed quickly, thoroughly and homogenously using minimum energy, reducing the carbon footprint of the new installation.

 F Ball naturally wanted to confirm all this, so John R Boone provided a test mixer on site so that the efficiency of the Delta Blade mixer could be thoroughly tested with F Ball’s materials, checking that they could achieve the batch times that they needed.

 Since entering service a further benefit of the Delta Blade system has been noted due to its highly efficient mixing action and despite the abrasive nature of the materials in use, no wear parts have been replaced in over two year’s operation.

 As Steve Tubby, F Ball’s Operations Director, put it; ‘Our experience of Boone’s since we installed the Rotary Drum Mixers back in 1991 has always been very positive, we have been able to rely on their support whenever we have needed it.  The Delta Blade mixer was exactly what we were looking for, a fast, energy-efficient solution that gave a consistently high quality mix in the shortest time possible.  Boone’s engineers were extremely responsive throughout the project and clearly understood what we were trying to achieve.’

For any information about JR Boone's range of products please contact us

 

 
Case Study - JR Boone

Process plant design and Mixer specialist, J R Boone Ltd, has recently completed one of its more difficult assignments - building to a strict specification, a 1,500-litre capacity horizontal helical blade mixer (HHBM) - and all done in double-quick time. 

JR BooneAdams Foods, part of Kerrygold, chose the company to supply equipment for mixing milk powders with up to 35 per cent fat content and minor additives in batch sizes ranging from 400 litres to 1,500 litres, with bulk densities of up to 1,050kg/m3. J R Boone had previously developed a completely new short aspect ratio Ribbon Mixer (HHBM) by adopting a scientific approach to maximise mixing efficiency, with only four helical blades for any machine size. This combined with the company’s comprehensive knowledge - gained over 40 years supplying mixers to the food processing industries - provided machines with the versatility to mix powders, pastes and slurries with simplified cleaning and maintenance. The resulting wide range of mixers based on common design element could then be produced at a competitive price. This was the ideal starting point for the company to start developing a custom model to meet the specific requirements of Adams Foods. Boone’s managing director, Chris Boone, explains: “Adams wanted to retain their existing feed hoppers and their conveying and discharging systems, while at the same time increasing the mixing capacity from 1,200 litres with their old machine to 1,500. Because of all these factors, we could only work to the same limited height as the old machine.

So we took one of our 1,250 HHBM models and re-designed it into a U-trough. Which increased its capacity to 1,500 litres, and we gave it an ATEX rating to ensure that it complied with the EU directive on installation into an area where small amounts of sugar can create a potentially explosive atmosphere.” One of the main stipulations from Adams Foods was that the new mixer should not suffer the same irritating problems as the old one. 

The company wanted an end to sealing and maintenance difficulties, to troubles caused by pressurisation and occasional overfill, and to problems of re-starting when the machine had to be stopped with a full load on board.
Chris Boone says: ”We fitted air-purged, packed gland seals and wear sleeves to give long life and easy maintenance. And the mixer can be subjected to over-pressure and regular full-load starts without any problems - or leaks.” All this and our speedy installation too. “Our redesign took just a few days and we cut our manufacturing time to eight weeks,” adds Mr Boone. The new HHBM machines from J R Boone are nothing if adaptable. They can handle a large range of products from breakfast foods to molassed sugar, and from cake mixes to instant potato. Things like frozen foods, powdered drinks and dough for dog biscuits are also taken in their stride, and in a non-food context - the machines can tackle car body fillers, the formation of thick slurries and fine chemicals. Over at Adams Foods, John Vernon, the factory engineer is more than pleased. He said “from the first day in production to the present time, the mixer has exceeded all our expectations, greatly reducing maintenance and increasing productive time.”

John R Boone supplied a HHBM (Horizontal Helical Blade Mixer) to Adams Foods, increasing batch size, reducing maintenance costs and improving the productive time available for production. Cost-effective, reliable and flexible, test, design and manufacture took only a shade over eight weeks to complete.



 
Mixer - JR Boone

John R Boone and GC Hahn – a great combination

Summary:

John R Boone Ltd worked closely with GC Hahn UK, a major manufacturer of food ingredients and additives, to design and install a mixing system to meet exacting standards of hygiene and to handle very demanding formulations. The end result has been a great success, mixing Hahn’s most difficult materials to high standards while immediately reducing mixing the time by more than 25%.

Detail:

GC Hahn is a family company with a history that stretches back more than 150 years, supplying the global food industry with products that help determine the taste, texture and stability of foodstuffs from yoghurt and mousse to scones and bread. With offices in 32 countries, they are at the forefront of ingredient and additive technology. In the UK, they are celebrating their tenth anniversary at purpose-built premises in Mold, North Wales. GC Hahn holds the highest Halal accreditation outside Malaysia, as well as the highest Kosher standards, requiring stringent DNA testing on batches produced. A wide range of raw materials, including liquid oils, waxes and difficult, pressure-sensitive powders need to be blended to create free-flowing powders or granules. The nature of the food industry also means that as requirements vary, GC Hahn often has to respond to urgent requirements from customers, changing production plans.

When GC Hahn looked to increase mixing capacity, they therefore had a very demanding set of criteria to satisfy. No cross contamination, excellent mixing performance to ensure a homogenous final product, rapid mixing with the flexibility to blend a variety of materials. ATEX hazardous area approval for Zone 22 powder hazard was another pre-requisite. The UK operation is also keen to maintain a reputation as the technical leaders even within their own company – the UK operation being trusted with the most difficult products that GC Hahn makes anywhere.

John R Boone supported GC Hahn throughout the project, from early evaluation of production materials, testing of mixer types and design of mixer blade configuration to supplying a test mixer for production trials to assisting with the design of the entire blending complex within the factory.

At the heart of the installation is a Boone 2000 model horizontal helical blade mixer, HHBM for short, tailored to suit GC Hahn’s exact requirements.

Components of some blends are pressure sensitive and need to be mixed gently to make sure they don’t agglomerate, other mixtures require a higher level of shear and with this in mind John R Boone designed the mixer with a replaceable mixer centre to enable the Paddle Blade or Delta Blade type agitator to be fitted and give GC Hahn complete flexibility. In Helical blade configuration, the product is lifted equally inwardly, outwardly and obliquely, with a very gentle action.

Overall, mixing time has been reduced by more than 25%, and tests are under way with the intention of reducing mixing time still further.

To meet ATEX criteria, the mixer is pressure rated to PED PD 5500. To meet the hygiene standards, which mean that the mixer has to be cleaned regularly by hand rather than using a CIP system, large access doors are required. John R Boone developed a clever pivot system to make sure that the doors are both large enough for access and easy to open yet close with little effort and form a gas tight pressure rated seal.

John R Boone installed and commissioned the system, including all the support structure, feed system and a hopper to discharge to the packaging line.

A very good working relationship has been built up between GC Hahn and JR Boone. As Darrel Wynne, UK Plant Manager of GC Hahn UK put it, “ Our business is a living thing, it’s moving and we have to move with our customers. John R Boone have worked with us every step of the way, and they continue to help us refine and develop the process”.

 


Brolton Group Pty Ltd